| TERM | JUSTICES |
| Spring 1790 | William Cushing John Jay |
| Fall 1790 | William Cushing John Jay |
| Spring 1791 | William Cushing John Jay |
| Fall 1791 | William Cushing John Jay |
| Spring 1792 | William Cushing John Jay |
| Fall 1792 | James Iredell James Wilson |
| Spring 1793 | William Cushing James Wilson |
| Fall 1793 | John Blair, Jr. James Wilson |
| Spring 1794 | William Cushing William Paterson James Wilson |
| Fall 1794 | William Cushing William Paterson |
| Spring 1795 | James Iredell |
| Fall 1795 | William Cushing |
| Spring 1796 | Samuel Chase |
| Fall 1796 | William Cushing |
| Spring 1797 | Oliver Ellsworth |
| Fall 1797 | William Cushing |
| Spring 1798 | William Cushing Oliver Ellsworth William Paterson |
| Fall 1798 | Oliver Ellsworth William Paterson |
| Spring 1799 | Samuel Chase |
| Fall 1799 | William Cushing Oliver Ellsworth William Paterson |
| Spring 1800 | William Cushing William Paterson Bushrod Washington |
| Fall 1800 | William Cushing William Paterson |