| JUSTICE | FROM | TO |
| Thomas Todd | 3-3-1807 | 2-7-1826 |
| Robert Trimble | 7-10-1826* | 8-25-1828 |
| John McLean | 5-4-1829** | 4-4-1861 |
| Noah Haynes Swayne | 3-21-1862 | 4-7-1867 |
| David Davis | 4-8-1867 | 3-4-1877 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 4-22-1878 | 12-18-1892 |
| Melville Weston Fuller | 12-19-1892 | 4-1-1894 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 4-2-1894 | 2-2-1896 |
| Henry Billings Brown | 2-3-1896 | 3-8-1903 |
| William Rufus Day | 3-9-1903 | 3-17-1912 |
| David Josiah Brewer | 9-2-1907 | 10-14-1907 |
| Horace Harmon Lurton | 3-18-1912 | 7-12-1914 |
| James Clark McReynolds | 10-19-1914 | 10-29-1916 |
| John Hessin Clarke | 10-30-1916 | 9-18-1922 |
| George Sutherland | 10-16-1922 | 3-15-1925 |
| Pierce Butler | 3-16-1925 | 4-9-1929 |
| Willis Van Devanter | 4-10-1929 | 6-2-1937 |
| Benjamin Nathan Cardozo | 11-8-1937 | 7-9-1938 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 2-6-1939 | 4-23-1939 |
| William Orville Douglas | 4-24-1939 | 2-11-1940 |
| Frank Murphy | 2-12-1940 | 10-13-1941 |
| James Francis Byrnes | 10-14-1941 | 10-3-1942 |
| Frank Murphy | 3-1-1943 | 7-19-1949 |
| Sherman Minton | 10-14-1949 | 10-15-1956 |
| Harold Hitz Burton | 10-16-1956 | 3-24-1957 |
| Tom C. Clark | 3-25-1957 | 6-12-1967 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 6-24-1957 | 10-13-1958 |
| Abe Fortas | 6-16-1967 | 10-8-1967 |
| Thurgood Marshall | 10-9-1967 | 1-6-1972 |
| William Hubbs Rehnquist | 1-7-1972 | 12-18-1975 |
| John Paul Stevens | 12-19-1975 | 6-28-2010 |
| Stephen Gerald Breyer | 6-29-2010 | 9-27-2010 |
| Elena Kagan | 9-28-2010 | 10-18-2018 |
| Brett M. Kavanaugh | 10-19-2018 | 11-19-2020 |
| Amy Coney Barrett | 11-20-2020 | present |
| *The exact date of Trimble's allotment to the Seventh Circuit, presumably pursuant to a presidential order, is unknown. The first documented Supreme Court order allotting him is dated January Term 1827. The order book of the U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Ohio in Columbus, however, indicates that Trimble began his service on the circuit courts on July 10, 1826, so that date is used here. | ||
| **The rough minutes of the Supreme Court indicate that McLean was allotted to the Seventh Circuit by an order of President Andrew Jackson of unspecified date. A newspaper account, however, indicates that McLean began his service on the circuit courts on May 4, 1829, at the U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Kentucky in Frankfort, so that date is used here. | ||