| JUSTICE | FROM | TO |
| William Paterson | 4-29-1802 | 3-2-1803 |
| Bushrod Washington | 3-3-1803 | 11-26-1829 |
| Henry Baldwin | 1-6-1830* | 4-21-1844 |
| Robert Cooper Grier | 8-15-1846 | 1-31-1870 |
| William Strong | 3-21-1870 | 12-14-1880 |
| Joseph P. Bradley | 1-10-1881 | 1-22-1892 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 2-1-1892 | 10-16-1892 |
| George Shiras, Jr. | 10-17-1892 | 2-23-1903 |
| Henry Billings Brown | 3-9-1903 | 5-28-1906 |
| Edward Douglass White | 5-29-1906 | 12-23-1906 |
| William Henry Moody | 12-24-1906 | 11-19-1910 |
| Horace Harmon Lurton | 1-9-1911 | 3-17-1912 |
| Mahlon Pitney | 3-18-1912 | 12-31-1922 |
| Pierce Butler | 1-22-1923 | 3-15-1925 |
| Louis Dembitz Brandeis | 3-16-1925 | 6-1-1930 |
| Owen Josephus Roberts | 6-2-1930 | 7-31-1945 |
| Harold Hitz Burton | 10-15-1945 | 10-15-1956 |
| William Joseph Brennan, Jr. | 10-16-1956 | 7-19-1990 |
| William Hubbs Rehnquist | 7-20-1990 | 8-7-1990 |
| John Paul Stevens | 8-7-1990 | 10-8-1990 |
| David Hackett Souter | 10-9-1990 | 6-29-2009 |
| Samuel A. Alito, Jr. | 6-30-2009 | present |
| *The minutes of the Supreme Court indicate that Baldwin took his seat on the Court on January 18, 1830, and presented an order of unspecified date, signed by President Andrew Jackson, allotting him to the Third Circuit. Jackson's order must have been issued between Baldwin's appointment date of January 6, 1830, and the date Baldwin presented the order, January 18, 1830, so the former date is used here. | ||