| JUSTICE | FROM | TO |
| William Cushing | 4-29-1802 | 9-13-1810 |
| Joseph Story | 3-14-1812 | 9-10-1845 |
| Levi Woodbury | 10-1-1845* | 9-4-1851 |
| Benjamin Robbins Curtis | 10-10-1851 | 9-30-1857 |
| Nathan Clifford | 2-15-1858 | 5-1-1881 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 5-2-1881 | 1-29-1882 |
| Horace Gray | 1-30-1882 | 9-15-1902 |
| Rufus Wheeler Peckham | 10-20-1902 | 12-7-1902 |
| Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | 12-8-1902 | 1-12-1932 |
| Louis Dembitz Brandeis | 3-28-1932 | 2-13-1939 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 4-24-1939 | 8-28-1962 |
| Arthur Joseph Goldberg | 10-15-1962 | 7-26-1965 |
| Abe Fortas | 10-11-1965 | 5-14-1969 |
| William Joseph Brennan, Jr. | 5-26-1969 | 7-19-1990 |
| William Hubbs Rehnquist | 7-20-1990 | 8-7-1990 |
| Harry Andrew Blackmun | 8-7-1990 | 10-8-1990 |
| David Hackett Souter | 10-9-1990 | 6-29-2009 |
| Stephen Gerald Breyer | 6-30-2009 | 6-30-2022 |
| John Glover Roberts, Jr. | 6-30-2022 | 9-27-2022 |
| Ketanji Brown Jackson | 9-28-2022 | present |
| *The exact date of Woodbury's allotment to the First Circuit, presumably pursuant to a presidential order, is unknown. The first documented Supreme Court order allotting him is dated March 4, 1846. The docket book for the U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Maine in Portland, however, indicates that Woodbury began his service on the circuit courts on October 1, 1845, so that date is used here. | ||